Superior Farms

USDA: Fine Superior Farms for Botched Animal Handling at Slaughterhouse

Cheryl Leahy Animals, Investigations, Legal Advocacy, News Leave a Comment

Following Animal Outlook’s first-ever undercover investigation of a lamb slaughterhouse in the U.S., we blew the whistle on Superior Farms, alleging violations of the Humane Methods of Slaughter Act (HMSA). On August 12 of this year, the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) found that an incident where a sheep was stunned several times before being rendered unconscious was “an egregious act of inhumane handling of animals in connection with slaughter…this is a violation” of the regulations under the HMSA.   

When Animal Outlook investigator Scott David completed the investigation, Animal Outlook filed a False Claims Act lawsuit against the facility. Animal Outlook’s suit alleged that Superior Farms had committed fraud against the government by violating the Humane Methods of Slaughter Act while fulfilling contracts for federal food assistance programs. In 2019, this case became the first-ever intervention and settlement by the U.S. Department of Justice over animal handling allegations at a ritual slaughter establishment. As a part of this settlement, Superior Farms’ parent company Transhumance entered into a consent decree with the USDA involving oversight and compliance with the law.

Superior Farms Consent Decree

The consent decree requires that Superior Farms abide by animal handling and slaughter regulations. These regulations require that stunning methods “produce immediate unconsciousness.” 

Animal Outlook swiftly moved to pen a letter to the USDA requesting that the agency fine Superior Farms for violating the 2019 consent decree. 

We strongly urge the USDA to do its part in enforcing the law intended to provide basic protections for animals in the final moments before they are killed.

Superior Farms is proof that farmed animals suffer. Animal Outlook’s legal team works diligently to hold the animal agriculture industry accountable for its cruel treatment of animals.

As part of our 25th anniversary all donations made will be matching by a group of generous donors. Your donation today to support our legal team and brave investigators will have double the impact in helping animals. Please visit 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *