Victory
No legal cases match this filter.
Victories & Settlements
Victory
Settled
Harvey’s Market — Foie Gras Lawsuit
On November 26, 2024, Harvey’s Market submitted a response to the court asserting that it had discontinued the sale of foie gras after receiving notice of our lawsuit. On October 15, 2024, Animal Outlook and Legal Impact for Chickens filed a lawsuit in the …continue reading
Settled
Alderfer Farms
The court gave final approval to the settlement of the federal class action based on Alderfer’s “free-roaming” claims. Alderfer must pay $287,500 and remove all “free-roaming” language from its egg packaging and marketing materials. On December 1, 2023, Animal Outlook and Richman Law & …continue reading
Settled
Iowa VSD Records
Under Iowa’s Open Records Law, Animal Outlook requested and received documents related to the mass extermination of chickens on farms in Buena Vista County, Iowa, in response to the 2021-2022 bird flu outbreak. Those documents detailed the use of Ventilation Shutdown Plus (VSD+) to …continue reading
Convicted
Jannat Farm Prosecutions (Tyson Grower)
From August to November of 2022, an Animal Outlook investigator worked undercover at Jannat Farm in Virginia, a facility contracted by Tyson Foods to raise chickens for meat, documenting a flock of 150,000 birds. The investigator obtained footage not only of pervasive, systemic cruelty, …continue reading
Victory
Bravo Packing Pet Food Contamination
Animal Outlook submitted a detailed complaint against Bravo Packing, Inc. (no affiliation with Bravo Pet Foods) to the FDA and the New Jersey Department of Health on December 10, 2020, after we tested a sample of Bravo’s Performance Dog frozen raw pet food and …continue reading
Victory
California Proposition 12 Lawsuit
Status: On May 11, 2023, the Supreme Court affirmed the 9th Circuit’s dismissal of the case, thereby ending the case with Proposition 12 intact. The Court’s opinion vindicates the right of all of us to stand up and refuse to be complicit in cruel …continue reading
Victory
Superior Farms Lawsuit
Status: Victory – Case settled with consent decree ordering Superior Farms to pay a substantial fine and implement training and procedures for humane slaughter Following our 2017 undercover investigation at Superior Farms, the first ever look inside a United States lamb slaughterhouse, Animal Outlook …continue reading
Victory
“Humane” Claims Lawsuit
On February 11, 2014, a consumer of Simple Truth chicken—Kroger, Co.’s store brand—filed a class-action lawsuit in the Superior Court of California in the County of Los Angeles alleging that the grocery giant is falsely and deceptively touting its Simple Truth chicken as having …continue reading
Convicted
Quanah Cattle Company Prosecutions
In 2013, an Animal Outlook undercover investigator worked inside Quanah Cattle Co. (QCC), an animal agribusiness company in Kersey, Colorado that purchases newborn calves from surrounding dairy factories and temporarily confines them before shipping them out to be raised for their meat. Just days …continue reading
Victory
Cal-Cruz Hatcheries Lawsuit
Animal Outlook documented shocking abuses of newly-hatched chicks and ducklings at Cal-Cruz Hatcheries in a 2009 undercover investigation. We immediately turned the video over to the law enforcement authorities at the Santa Cruz County Animal Services Authority and the District Attorney’s Office. In response, …continue reading
Victory
Dairy Price Fixing Lawsuit
The dairy industry has consistently shown its lack of regard for animal welfare and the environment. Now it’s milking its own consumers by illegally jacking up prices. On Monday, Sept. 26, 2011 several dairy consumers, including members of Animal Outlook (then Compassion Over Killing), …continue reading
Victory
“Animal Care Certified” Eggs Petition
Status: Victory – The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) announced that the United Egg Producers (UEP) deceptive logo would no longer be stamped on egg cartons nationwide From 2002 to 2005, the majority of U.S. egg producers labeled their egg cartons with a logo that …continue reading
Convicted
Tyson Foods Prosecutions (Case 1)
Status: Victory – 9 employees convicted on 22 counts of animal cruelty Following our groundbreaking 2016 investigation into Tyson Foods’ broiler breeder factory farms in Virginia, Animal Outlook’s vigorous pursuit of prosecution led to the conviction of nine former employees on 22 counts of …continue reading
Victory
Hormel Lawsuit (Amicus)
Animal Outlook, along with two other animal protection organizations, filed an amicus curiae brief (“friend of the court” brief) in the District of Columbia Court of Appeals in support of Animal Legal Defense Fund’s (ALDF) false advertising lawsuit against Hormel. In 2016, ALDF sued …continue reading
Convicted
Bravo Criminal Prosecution
Following Animal Outlook’s undercover investigation at Bravo Packing*, which slaughters cows and horses for animal feed and has operated for over 60 years, Animal Outlook filed a private criminal complaint against Bravo’s owner, Joseph Merola. In December 2022, as a result of Animal Outlook’s …continue reading
Convicted
Mason Dixon Dairy Prosecution
In 2017, an Animal Outlook investigation revealed violent abuse of gentle mother cows at Mason Dixon Farms, a massive dairy factory farm in Pennsylvania with more than 2,500 animals. The investigation documented egregious cruelty to animals including workers kicking cows in the face, punching …continue reading
Convicted
Tyson Foods Prosecution (Case 2)
For several weeks, an Animal Outlook investigator worked inside Atlantic Farm, a Temperanceville, Virginia facility with more than 225,000 birds crammed inside filthy warehouses. The investigation marked the second time in little more than a year that Animal Outlook has exposed horrific cruelty to …continue readingActive & Pending
Pending
Choice Hotels
Animal Outlook sued Choice Hotels under the D.C. Consumer Protection Procedures Act over its broken cage-free egg pledge and deceptive progress reporting. …continue reading
Pending
Cuisinery
Animal Outlook sued Cuisinery Food Market under California’s Unfair Competition Law for selling foie gras from force-fed birds, which California law prohibits. …continue reading
Pending
Drone Regulation Petition
Animal Outlook, FarmStand and We Animals filed a formal comment opposing an FAA proposed rule that could let animal agriculture facilities close the airspace above them to drones. …continue reading
Pending
Panera Bread — Deceptive Marketing Lawsuit
On March 20, 2026, Animal Outlook and co-counsel Richman Law & Policy filed a consumer protection lawsuit on behalf of Food Animal Concerns Trust (FACT) against Panera Bread and its parent company, JAB Holding Company, alleging misleading and deceptive marketing claims about animal welfare …continue reading
Pending
Ralphs — False Advertising Lawsuit
On March 20, 2026, Animal Outlook, as plaintiff and co-counsel with Pease & Ijadi, APC, filed a lawsuit against The Kroger Company and its wholly owned subsidiary Ralphs Grocery Company in Los Angeles County Superior Court, alleging violations of California’s Unfair Competition Law and …continue reading
Pending
Aldi
On March 20 2026, Animal Outlook filed a humane washing lawsuit against ALDI Inc. in the Superior Court of the District of Columbia, alleging violations of the District of Columbia Consumer Protection Procedures Act over the company’s broken cage-free egg pledge and deceptive animal …continue reading
Pending
Beat the Lag
In October 2022, Animal Outlook submitted a complaint with the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) about a dairy industry campaign targeting Gen Z online gamers. The campaign, called “Beat the Lag (BTL),” uses popular video gaming platforms, such as Twitch and YouTube, and well-known gaming …continue reading
Pending
American Heart Association suit over “heart healthy” meat certification
May 2025 Update: On May 2, 2025, Animal Outlook filed an appeal of the District of Columbia court’s dismissal of this lawsuit. In August 2022, Animal Outlook sued the American Heart Association (AHA) over the organization’s use of its “Heart-Check” certification mark on certain meat …continue readingConcluded
Completed
Oregon Recording Laws (Amicus)
Animal Outlook and three other advocacy organizations filed an amicus brief supporting Project Veritas’s First Amendment challenge to Oregon’s conversational privacy statute. …continue reading
Dismissed
Case Farms
December 2025 Update: The Supreme Court of North Carolina denied our Petition for Discretionary Review. May 2025 Update: After the trial court granted Case Farms’ motion to dismiss on December 15, 2023, the Court of Appeals of North Carolina upheld the dismissal on May 21, 2025. June 2023: Animal …continue reading
Completed
Foie Gras Law Enforcement
On December 13, 2021, a letter was submitted to Meagan Galligan, District Attorney for Sullivan County, NY, and Michael Schiff, Sheriff for Sullivan County. This letter informs District Attorney Galligan and Sheriff Schiff of ongoing violations of New York’s animal cruelty law by two …continue reading
Completed
Martin Farms Prosecution
January 2025 Update After losing in the Superior Court, the District Attorney’s office appealed to the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania. That court announced a change in the law in a different case, altering the standard of review for denials of private criminal complaints, and …continue reading
Dismissed
Cooke Aquaculture False Advertising
In April 2022, the judge in our lawsuit wrote that the cruelty we described was “grotesque and reprehensible,” though she dismissed the case for procedural reasons. Now Animal Outlook has submitted a petition, signed by over 150 registered Maine voters, that requires the Maine …continue reading
Dismissed
High-Speed Chicken Slaughter Lawsuit
On behalf of the billions of chickens slaughtered in the United States every year, Animal Outlook, alongside the Humane Society of the United States, the Government Accountability Project (GAP), Marin Humane Society, and Mercy for Animals, sued the USDA over its reckless high-speed slaughter …continue reading
Completed
High-Speed Pig Slaughter Lawsuit
On December 18, 2019, Animal Outlook joined six other animal protection organizations in filing a lawsuit against the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) challenging the agency’s decision to reduce oversight and eliminate line speed caps at pig slaughterhouses, exposing millions of pigs to …continue reading
Dismissed
Egg Labeling Lawsuit
On March 28, 2013, Animal Outlook (then Compassion Over Killing) and the Animal Legal Defense Fund (ALDF) co-filed a lawsuit against the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), two agencies within the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) and the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) for …continue reading
Dismissed
Foie Gras Lawsuit
Animal Outlook (formerly Compassion Over Killing), Animal Legal Defense Fund, Farm Sanctuary, and Animal Protection & Rescue League, and several concerned individuals joined forces to file a lawsuit against the US Department of Agriculture (USDA) for allowing the sale of a diseased poultry product …continue readingMallard
Mallard, a D.C. restaurant, advertised a foie gras dinner as "responsibly-farmed" one week after D.C. voters backed a foie gras sales ban. After Animal Outlook's letter, Mallard took down the deceptive advertising. …continue reading
Records Obtained
Hickman’s FOIAs
Animal Outlook’s public records request revealed that Hickman’s killed roughly 6.3 million hens using ventilation shutdown plus heat. …continue reading
Records Obtained
