Animal Outlook, along with two other animal protection organizations, filed an amicus curiae brief (“friend of the court” brief) in the District of Columbia Court of Appeals in support of Animal Legal Defense Fund’s (ALDF) false advertising lawsuit against Hormel.
In 2016, ALDF sued Hormel under the D.C. Consumer Protection Procedures Act, alleging the company is misleading consumers through the advertising of its Natural Choice® brand of lunch meats and bacon. ALDF argued that Hormel’s marketing campaign leads customers to incorrectly believe that the animals used in Natural Choice® products are treated humanely. The case was dismissed by the lower court and is now on appeal.
In the amicus curiae brief, Animal Outlook, Animal Equality, and The Humane League argue that such false advertising prevents consumers from choosing products derived from less cruel practices. The organizations argue that the lower court was wrong in holding that ALDF could not pursue its claim. Specifically, the lower court determined ALDF could not bring a consumer protection claim since, as an animal-protection organization, it operates to promote the interests “of the consumed” as opposed to the interests of consumers. The amicus brief pushes back against this misunderstanding of the organizations’ work, explaining how the interests of consumers and “the consumed” overlap in significant ways when it comes to truthful advertising.
The amicus brief explains how consumer education furthers the groups’ animal-protective missions because consumer demand can drive industry behavior, which in turn can result in meaningful changes for animals. For this reason, the brief asserts, “When a company such as Hormel claims that its practices are more humane than those of other producers, animal-protection organizations must expend additional resources showing that the company’s actual practices are no different from the cruelty standard in the industry. By falsely attempting to differentiate themselves by making baseless claims about the nature of their products, companies directly stymie animal protection groups’ efforts to educate consumers.”
“Humane-minded consumers have an interest in truthful advertising for the same reason the animals do: to avoid the perpetuation of animal suffering,” says Cheryl Leahy, Animal Outlook’s Executive Vice President. “Far from being mutually exclusive work, consumer protection efforts frequently redound to the benefit of animals as well.”
More news about this case:
• Animal Outlook
